• 137 Posts
  • 8.91K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 30th, 2023

help-circle



  • Please read the law and stop embarrassing yourself.

    I could say the same to you, but your reading comprehension and willingness to embarrass yourself to excuse Apartheid and genocide seem to be inversely proportional.

    I’ll not be engaging further as you are clearly arguing in bad faith, incapable of understanding any information that doesn’t conform with the Hasbara gaslighting you spread like an infection, or both.

    Have the day you deserve.



  • I’m including it because you seem to utterly unaware of international law.

    Is it opposite day already? Or just the Zionist Day of Projection, which is every day that ends in a y?

    Israel has attacked military objectives in safe zones

    A zone is by definition not safe if it contains a military objective. That’s so obvious that it’s frankly embarrassing for both of us that I have to point it out to you.

    That is legal under international law

    Would be if it wasn’t horseshit. The IDF claims phantom militants everywhere they bomb. In the vast majority of cases, there’s no legitimate military target.

    Hamas putting their weapons depots and operating bases in areas protected under international humanitarian law

    According to the IDF, an organization synonymous with concocting falsehoods to excuse deliberate targeting of civilians.

    is a war crime

    Even if they WEREN’T lying about there being Hamas bases there, bombing a hospital or a school or a refugee camp would STILL be a war crime.

    Nobody’s forcing Israel to kill civilians. Israel is TARGETING civilians, with the “bases” made up afterwards and never proven to exist in the vast majority of cases.

    Attacking these is not a war crime.

    Yes, it most certainly is. Forgetting for a second that there’s hardly ever any hostiles there, bombing civilians is a war crime.

    Imagine for a second that, unbeknownst to you, the guy who lives in the apartment below yours is a terrorist. Would that make it acceptable for your government to reduce the entire block to rubble, killing you and every other civilian in the process?

    I say no, and so does international law.



  • They are not citizens

    They by definition CAN’T be because Palestine doesn’t have any citizens. Because it’s occupied territory denied nationhood by its occupiers, Israel.

    Do you think a Palestinian state in the West Bank would accept Jewish settlers as citizens?

    Jewish people in general? Yes. Jewish (or Christian, or Muslim etc) SETTLERS stealing their land on behalf of an occupying force, though? That’s another kettle of ballgames entirely.

    “Settling” land already owned by someone else is colonialism and theft, not peaceful coexistence.




  • Viking_Hippie@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.worldInvestigate
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    19
    ·
    edit-2
    13 hours ago

    I hope you’re also against Palestinian nationalism then

    That’s not comparable and you know it. Nationalism without a nation is an ambition. Ethno-nationalism while in control of a nation containing other peoples is oppression and, in extreme cases like the South Africa of the past and present day Israel, Apartheid.

    But to answer the question you thought you asked: yes, I am against the violently theocratic government philosophy of Hamas.

    Also compare the number of Arabs with Israeli citizenship to the number of Jews with PA citizenship.

    Arab doesn’t equal Palestinian and Palestinian doesn’t equal Arab. To conflate the two is bigotry and ignorance.


  • Viking_Hippie@lemmy.worldtoMicroblog Memes@lemmy.worldInvestigate
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    12 hours ago

    In Gaza there is only temporary evacuations forced displacement of civilians from dangerous areas their homes. This is not only illegal but required under international humanitarian law as a war crime

    There, fixed it for you.

    Gazans are not constantly expelled from their land

    In fact, almost all Palestinians in Gaza have been forcibly displaced

    they aren’t allowed to leave the Gaza strip

    True, but not a good thing. The Israeli apartheid regime is basically moving Gazans around inside an open air prison in between the murder and the theft and destruction of those things necessary for people to live.


  • Zionism is simply Jewish nationalism

    That’s a big part of the problem. Ethnostates and theocracies are invariably oppressive towards any inhabitants who are not of the dominant ethnicity or religion. Israel is no exception and shouldn’t be treated as one.

    the right of self determination for the Jewish people in the form of a democratic state

    An Apartheid state, which a formalized ethnostate by definition is, is inherently anti democratic and opposed to the self determination of everyone except the ruling people. Self determination through oppression of others is never and will never be legitimate.