DroneRights [it/its]@lemm.ee to Shower Thoughts@kbin.socialEnglish · edit-21 year agoThe Hobbit is YAmessage-squaremessage-square9fedilinkarrow-up10arrow-down10
arrow-up10arrow-down1message-squareThe Hobbit is YADroneRights [it/its]@lemm.ee to Shower Thoughts@kbin.socialEnglish · edit-21 year agomessage-square9fedilink
minus-squareDamaskox@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·1 year agoYoung adult or teen’s story. I don’t recall the story having explicit or otherwise harmful material for kids.
minus-squarestarbreaker@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·11 months ago I don’t recall the story having explicit or otherwise harmful material for kids. Of course not; The Hobbit started out as bedtime stories Tolkien made up for his kids. But, to paraphrase the proverb, what happens in Rivendell stays in Rivendell. (Likewise for Lothlorien.)
minus-squareDamaskox@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·11 months agoYeah. I just don’t know what justifies a story to be rather an young adult story, if it would (otherwise?) fit (better) in a child’s story section 🤔 I mean - what makes The Hobbit an young adult story rather than a child’s? Violence? Sexual material?
minus-squarestarbreaker@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·11 months agoMarketing. YA is a marketing category, not a genre.
minus-squareDamaskox@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·11 months agoSo they use…a non-logical marketing category? Or there’s something I don’t understand 😅
minus-squarestarbreaker@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·11 months agoDon’t ask me, man. If I understood marketing or was any good at it I wouldn’t be fucking around with computers for a living.
minus-squareWHYAREWEALLCAPS@kbin.sociallinkfedilinkarrow-up0·1 year agoWhen I read it in my preteen youth in the early 80s it was in the “children’s section” of our local library in podunk Georgia.
Young adult fiction
Young adult or teen’s story.
I don’t recall the story having explicit or otherwise harmful material for kids.
Of course not; The Hobbit started out as bedtime stories Tolkien made up for his kids.
But, to paraphrase the proverb, what happens in Rivendell stays in Rivendell. (Likewise for Lothlorien.)
Yeah.
I just don’t know what justifies a story to be rather an young adult story, if it would (otherwise?) fit (better) in a child’s story section 🤔
I mean - what makes The Hobbit an young adult story rather than a child’s? Violence? Sexual material?
Marketing. YA is a marketing category, not a genre.
So they use…a non-logical marketing category?
Or there’s something I don’t understand 😅
Don’t ask me, man. If I understood marketing or was any good at it I wouldn’t be fucking around with computers for a living.
When I read it in my preteen youth in the early 80s it was in the “children’s section” of our local library in podunk Georgia.